Modified:
27 Nov 2008
by Dhc

Vote totals:

Yes:

67%

No:

33%

Neutral:

0%

 
Subscribe to Newsletter
Tell a Friend
(Use commas to separate)
Bookmark and Share
Subscribe to Debate

Join Mailing List

Key Links

Debatewise debate DEBATE: IT IS TIME TO STOP BUYING BOTTLED WATER

Bottled water is less healthy than tap water and plastic bottles are having a huge impact on the environment. It is time we stopped drinking bottled water.





Debatewise debateIT IS TIME TO STOP BUYING BOTTLED WATER


Its harmful to the environment


You end up with a bottle that needs to be recycled and often isn’t
85% of plastic water bottles become garbage.
The bottling companies find it easier and more profitable to let you throw the water containers away and buy a new one each time.
About 2 million of them are thrown away every hour.
Most bottles sold are actually small sized bottles, increasing the wastage

There are environmental costs to purifying tap water too. Not to forget the toxic materials necessary to pump and deliver the water to the tap.
Moreover the problems you raise are more with the bottles themselves and how we dispose of them than with the concept of bottled water per se. Biodegradable corn starch ‘polymers’ or a more responsible attitude to recycling would also solve the problem.


What do you think?  Vote on this point below.
Absolutely Agree For
Strongly Agree For
Mostly Agree For
Partially Agree For
Neutral
Partially Agree Against
Mostly Agree Against
Strongly Agree Against
Absolutely Agree Against

Debatewise debateIT IS TIME TO STOP BUYING BOTTLED WATER


People believe the marketing hype too much


Marketing, that’s all it is. Like Madonna, it’s all hype.
The elemental problem with the purchase and continuation of the bottled water industry is the marketing of it; if bottled water were advertised simply as a means to hydration in the same way that juices, fruits themselves, tap water, etc. are seen by the general public, then it may soon be realised that the coincidental nature of the sounds of the words ‘l’evian’ and ‘live young’ are just that: a coincidence. Water that has trickled through mountains for hundreds of years will not be like ‘manna from heaven’ trickling from the edges of the holy grail, it’s just H2O.



Debatewise debateIT IS TIME TO STOP BUYING BOTTLED WATER


Bottled water is good where there is a lack of healthy water


We actually need some healthy water where taps can not provide that.

This doesn’t apply to most Western countries though and people there could easily rely on tap water for their needs.


What do you think?  Vote on this point below.
Absolutely Agree For
Strongly Agree For
Mostly Agree For
Partially Agree For
Neutral
Partially Agree Against
Mostly Agree Against
Strongly Agree Against
Absolutely Agree Against

Debatewise debateIT IS TIME TO STOP BUYING BOTTLED WATER


Bottled water costs up to 1,000 times the price of tap water


Why when it comes cheaply out the tap would you pay 1,000 times more? Volcanicity perhaps…

Sometimes I am prepared to pay ‘up to 1,000 times the price of tap water’ for the convience of not having to carry water around with me. I can just buy a bottle when I need it and dispose of it when I’m finished. I’m prepared to pay a premuim for that.


What do you think?  Vote on this point below.
Absolutely Agree For
Strongly Agree For
Mostly Agree For
Partially Agree For
Neutral
Partially Agree Against
Mostly Agree Against
Strongly Agree Against
Absolutely Agree Against

Debatewise debateIT IS TIME TO STOP BUYING BOTTLED WATER


Its no better for you.


The source of your bottled water is likely to be the same one that serves your home.
Coke revealed last year that the source of it´s highly publicized Dasani Brand water was London’s municipal water supply (with a 3000% markup).
PepsiCos Aquafina Brand bottled water is treated tap water coming from 11 different wells around the USA.
Mostly the only difference is that bottled water has added minerals and salts, which do not actually mean the water is healthier.
Drinking water is better for your teeth as it contains flourides. Bottled water does not.

The proposition forgets that most bottled waters marketed in this country are "mineral" or "spring" waters. For a water to possess the name of "mineral" or "spring" water, it must come from a spring in the ground and be bottled at source. Waters such as Dasani are unpopular – Dasani itself was itself completely withdrawn from sale in the UK. The bottled waters popular in this country, i.e. Evian, Volvic, San Pellegrino, Buxton, all come from natural springs and contain natural elements, such as iron, potassium etc, which are all necessary for the human body to function healthily. Often, some natural flourides occur in mineral water. Fluorides are only sometimes artificially added to tap waters, and in large quantities this has the undesired effect of staining teeth instead of improving their health. Tap water is often highly chlorinated. Bottled water does have a health benefit and is better than tap water.


What do you think?  Vote on this point below.
Absolutely Agree For
Strongly Agree For
Mostly Agree For
Partially Agree For
Neutral
Partially Agree Against
Mostly Agree Against
Strongly Agree Against
Absolutely Agree Against

Debatewise debateIT IS TIME TO STOP BUYING BOTTLED WATER


Bottled water is often just tapwater anyway


It is often just straight from the tap and therefore no better for you than tap water. Case in point: The Coca-Cola company attempted to release Dasani water in the UK, which was just filtered tap water. It is still on sale in the USA.

In the UK the terms ‘natural mineral water’ and ‘spring water’ denote water from an aquifer or underground source, with rules on hygiene and mineral content. Similar laws on how you describe your product exist in the US. If you’re stupid enough to pay a premium for something which just says ‘water, product of the Coca-Cola company’ then you probably deserve getting the hefty dose of bromide that came free in bottles of Dasani.
More importantly, whether or not the bottled water comes from the tap, there is still the convenience of being able to purchase, albeit at a premium, water without having to carry a bottle around with you. Moreover if you were, say, travelling in India, or any similar area, the very process of filtering the tap water is rather useful given the reputation of the country’s ‘potable’ water supply.


What do you think?  Vote on this point below.
Absolutely Agree For
Strongly Agree For
Mostly Agree For
Partially Agree For
Neutral
Partially Agree Against
Mostly Agree Against
Strongly Agree Against
Absolutely Agree Against

Debatewise debateIT IS TIME TO STOP BUYING BOTTLED WATER


Water quality


The quality of water is very high in this country is very good. In foreign countries bottled water is only consumed because they cannot drink the tap water. There is no need to drink it.

Just because the quality of something is high does not mean that we should not have the right to drink it if we so wish. If we banned bottled water because "we don’t need it" where would this lead? We don’t need toasters – we can make fire. We don’t need washing machines because we can use the river. We don’t need cars because we’ve got legs. Banning bottled water would start an irreversible trend of banning that which it can be argued we don’t need.


What do you think?  Vote on this point below.
Absolutely Agree For
Strongly Agree For
Mostly Agree For
Partially Agree For
Neutral
Partially Agree Against
Mostly Agree Against
Strongly Agree Against
Absolutely Agree Against

Debatewise debateIT IS TIME TO STOP BUYING BOTTLED WATER


It enhances enjoyment and feeling of wellbeing


Walking in the countryside, playing chess or swimming may improve one’s sense of well-being – but these activities have no detrimental consequences for the wider environment. This is not just a reference to the scientifically debatable concept of ‘carbon footprints’ &c. involved in bottle production and transit, but to the landfill and litter that the consumption of bottled water inevitably produces.
If it is the feeling of wellbeing one seeks, then purchase only one bottle, and re-fill it, as required from the tap, or perhaps a tabletop water filter. One doesn’t need to keep purchasing bottled water to feel good.

Many products that are availabe on the market have little or no proven physical effect on a person’s wellbeing, but why should someone be denied the FEELING of improving their health?
Stripey socks do little to enhance a person’s life or wellbeing, and arguably uses valuable cotton resources and environment-harming dyes, yet one would be hard pushed to find a group to lobby against them!


What do you think?  Vote on this point below.
Absolutely Agree For
Strongly Agree For
Mostly Agree For
Partially Agree For
Neutral
Partially Agree Against
Mostly Agree Against
Strongly Agree Against
Absolutely Agree Against

Debatewise debateIT IS TIME TO STOP BUYING BOTTLED WATER


Invaluable for aid in natural disasters/famine


It is conceivable that should the demand for bottled water dwindle, manufacturers would have to shut down production in many factories. This would make bottled water less widely available and therefore more expensive.
It logically follows that this added expense and dwindling availability would effect aid and charity agencies who rely on cheap, readily availabe bottled water supplies for helping with widespread floods, and other natural disasters.



Debatewise debateIT IS TIME TO STOP BUYING BOTTLED WATER


Invaluable for travellers in areas with unsafe tap water


We could, if we could be bothered, take water purification devices with us. The inconvenience suffered would be far preferable than seeing beautiful paradise islands overcome by plastic bottles, as has happened in Thailand to my knowledge and I’m sure other places too.
We have a responsibility when we travel, the responsibility to leave the place as we found it – as much as we possibly can. Dumping water bottles ruins an environment for decades to come. Taking our own means of purifying water is the responsible thing to do.

In a cosmopolitan age, many tourists and business people wish, or are required to travel to areas of the globe where tap water is dangerous to drink, or simply not available.
However costly, bottled water provides a solution to the problem of water availability in such areas.
Given the length of time it takes to squeeze a cupful of water through a reverse osmosis pump, I suspect bottled water is here to stay for travellers.
Drinking ‘dirty but ‘purified’ water is ALWAYS a last resort for travellers. Also it tastes disgusting which is a pretty minor point morally speaking, but in any case will still affect large numbers of people.
Make it safe and not taste as horrible then try to convince people.


What do you think?  Vote on this point below.
Absolutely Agree For
Strongly Agree For
Mostly Agree For
Partially Agree For
Neutral
Partially Agree Against
Mostly Agree Against
Strongly Agree Against
Absolutely Agree Against

Debatewise debateIT IS TIME TO STOP BUYING BOTTLED WATER