Modified:
27 Nov 2008
by Admin

Vote totals:

Yes:

100%

No:

0%

Neutral:

0%

 
Subscribe to Newsletter
Tell a Friend
(Use commas to separate)
Bookmark and Share
Subscribe to Debate

Join Mailing List

Key Links

Debatewise debate DEBATE: DIGITAL SLR CAMERAS ARE BETTER THAN COMPACT DIGITAL

I am a digital SLR enthusiast - my web site probably gives that away. I think that there are many advantages of digital SLR cameras. But I also know that there are many features of compact digital cameras that aren't available on digital SLRs. This debate presents both sides of the coin so that you can make an informed camera-buying decision





Debatewise debateDIGITAL SLR CAMERAS ARE BETTER THAN COMPACT DIGITAL


Built For Speed


It’s electronics vs. mechanics.
There’s a device called a shutter that sits in front of the digital SLR sensor, blocking it from light.
When you take a photo, the shutter (made up of two curtains) opens and closes.
This is different from a compact camera, where there is no shutter mechanism. In compact cameras, the sensor is electronically activated every time you take a photo.
The advantage of the mechanical solution is that it is instantaneous: you press the shutter button and the shutter snaps open.
There’s never a delay when you want to capture that photo of a lifetime.
(www.digital-slr-guide.com)



Debatewise debateDIGITAL SLR CAMERAS ARE BETTER THAN COMPACT DIGITAL


A Lens For Every Occasion


If I want to take landscape photos, I attach a wide-angle lens. If I want to photograph bugs and flowers, I use a macro lens. When I take photos of my labrador, I use a telephoto lens and can snap shots even when I’m halfway across a field.
One camera, tons of lenses.Again, it comes down to speed.
Zoom lenses in compact cameras take time to zoom in and out since the zoom is driven by a motor. You manually control the zoom of a digital SLR, and can zoom as fast or slow as you like.
(www.digital-slr-guide.com)



Debatewise debateDIGITAL SLR CAMERAS ARE BETTER THAN COMPACT DIGITAL


High Quality in Low-Light


One clear advantage of digital SLR cameras is that they’re able to capture photos even when there’s not a lot of ambient light.
So what? Every camera can take a photo when there’s not a lot of light – just turn on the flash.
Here’s the trick: digital SLR cameras can do it without the flash.Digital SLRs are able to take photos when there’s little available light because of a feature called ISO: it makes the digital sensor more sensitive to light.
While several compact digital cameras will also let you change the ISO of the camera, there is one key difference.
As you increase the ISO (and increase the camera’s sensitivity to light) you also add grain or "noise" to the image.
The advantage of digital SLR cameras when it comes to ISO is that even at high ISO settings they produce very little noise. I can’t say the same about compact cameras.
If you really enjoy taking photos when there’s not a lot of light, the image quality of a digital SLR will exceed a compact any day of the week.
(www.digital-slr-guide.com)

Any camera can make correct exposures in low light settings. Aside from having adjustable film speed, virtually every Compact Digital camera available has adjustable shutter speed and aperture size.
Also, since the noise inherent in higher ISO’s is the result of the film or digital sensor’s sensitivity to light, high ISO exposures taken on a DSLR are every bit as noisy as high ISO exposures taken on a CD. The graininess has nothing to do with the type of camera.


What do you think?  Vote on this point below.
Absolutely Agree For
Strongly Agree For
Mostly Agree For
Partially Agree For
Neutral
Partially Agree Against
Mostly Agree Against
Strongly Agree Against
Absolutely Agree Against

Debatewise debateDIGITAL SLR CAMERAS ARE BETTER THAN COMPACT DIGITAL


You Have Control


This is my favorite advantage of digital SLR cameras.
I don’t like a machine to be making decisions for me. While it’s right most of the time, it isn’t right ALL of the time. The human brain will always be better at judging a scene then a camera set to automatic.
With a digital SLR, you have complete control over every photo you take, and don’t have to rely on the camera to make choices for you.
Even if you’re not ready to make the jump to a fully manual camera, don’t be frightened off.
Every digital SLR camera lets you use an automatic setting, and provides you with intermediate steps that offer increasing levels of control over your images.
(www.digital-slr-guide.com)

DSLR’s do present a higher degree of creative control over your exposure, but virtually every single CD camera currently available has a manual setting that allows you control over aperture and shutter speed. The camera only makes your choices for you if you want it to.


What do you think?  Vote on this point below.
Absolutely Agree For
Strongly Agree For
Mostly Agree For
Partially Agree For
Neutral
Partially Agree Against
Mostly Agree Against
Strongly Agree Against
Absolutely Agree Against

Debatewise debateDIGITAL SLR CAMERAS ARE BETTER THAN COMPACT DIGITAL


Price


Even though the price has been dropping on digital SLRs, they are still significantly more expensive than their compact cousins.An inexpensive digital SLR camera starts around $500 – and that’s often without a lens.
Tack on an additional $100 for a kit lens or $500 for a higher-quality zoom.
If you can’t fathom spending $800 to $1,000 on a digital camera, then an SLR is definitely not right for you.
(www.digital-slr-guide.com)



Debatewise debateDIGITAL SLR CAMERAS ARE BETTER THAN COMPACT DIGITAL


No Movie Mode


Right up until September of 2008, this was a huge difference between digital SLRs and compact digital cameras.
SLRs are mostly focused on capturing still images, not video.
But in September of 2008, Nikon released a camera called the D90 – the first digital SLR that can capture both still photos AND High Definition (HD) video.
Hot on the heels of the D90 came the announcement of the new Canon 5D Mark II – the second digital SLR that captures photos and video (also HD).
While the addition of a movie mode appears to be an emerging trend in the digital SLR market, the vast majority of old and even new SLR cameras can not capture video.
(www.digital-slr-guide.com)



Debatewise debateDIGITAL SLR CAMERAS ARE BETTER THAN COMPACT DIGITAL


Limited Live View


A Surprising difference between SLR and compact digital cameras is that some SLRs don’t have a live preview mode (especially models released prior to 2007).
The LCD is only good for reviewing shots that you’ve already taken – it won’t show you the photo you’re about to take.
This means that you must compose all your photos by looking through the viewfinder.
Many newer digital SLR cameras allow you to compose photos using both the LCD and the viewfinder (these are called live view digital SLRs), but they all have one huge limitation: the sophisticated autofocus systems that SLRs are renowned for don’t work very well in "live view" mode.
For now, live view on SLRs is fine if you to take photos of static subjects, but it’s impossible to use for any type of action photography.
(www.digital-slr-guide.com)



Debatewise debateDIGITAL SLR CAMERAS ARE BETTER THAN COMPACT DIGITAL


Size and Weight


If your idea of the ultimate camera is something that fits in your pocket, then forget all about digital SLRs.
The most obvious difference between SLR and compact digital cameras (besides price) is sheer size. Even a small-sized digital SLR camera is twice the size and bulk of a compact camera.
While there are many new digital SLR models that are more portable (and are easier to travel with) the addition of a lens to your camera ensures that you’ll never be able to stow it away in your pants.
(www.digital-slr-guide.com)




Vote on the overall debate: Digital SLR cameras are better than Compact Digital

What do you think?  Vote on this point below.
Absolutely Agree For
Strongly Agree For
Mostly Agree For
Partially Agree For
Neutral
Partially Agree Against
Mostly Agree Against
Strongly Agree Against
Absolutely Agree Against

Comments about this debate

There are no comments for this debate


Add your own comment

Login or register to leave a comment
Loading...