Modified:
07 Oct 2008
by Admin

Vote totals:

Yes:

100%

No:

0%

Neutral:

0%

 
Subscribe to Newsletter
Tell a Friend
(Use commas to separate)
Bookmark and Share
Subscribe to Debate

Join Mailing List

Key Links

Debatewise debate DEBATE: REPRESENTATIVE DEMOCRACY IS A BETTER FORM OF GOVERNMENT THAN DIRECT DEMOCRACY.

Many people feel that direct democracy could work to reduce voter apathy and place national and local issues directly in the hands of those they affect most. However, this system has its own problems, particularly practicality and self-interest, and may not even effectively address the political issues that many of its supporters think that it will solve.





Debatewise debateREPRESENTATIVE DEMOCRACY IS A BETTER FORM OF GOVERNMENT THAN DIRECT DEMOCRACY.


Representative democracy is far better suited to dealing with a large electorate.


Direct democracy may work very well among a small group of people, but the larger the group the more difficult it is to run effectively. Representative democracy eliminates this difficulty by operating on a much smaller scale the majority of the time (via elected representatives of the electorate as a whole).



Debatewise debateREPRESENTATIVE DEMOCRACY IS A BETTER FORM OF GOVERNMENT THAN DIRECT DEMOCRACY.


The complexity of many political issues would make some of them difficult for the average voter to understand.


Political issues can be exceptionally complicated and take MPs a lot of time and consultation with experts to fully understand themselves, before they can be considered informed enough to vote. Educating the whole electorate on such issues would be exceptionally difficult for a number of reasons, and if an uninformed electorate were to vote on issues the results could be incredibly damaging.



Debatewise debateREPRESENTATIVE DEMOCRACY IS A BETTER FORM OF GOVERNMENT THAN DIRECT DEMOCRACY.


The welfare of the society would be sidelined for the needs of the individual.


The average individual voter would put his or her needs before those of society as a whole. This self-interest is perfectly natural, but if a law that benefits a smaller group does not benefit a larger group (for example, the protection of minority interests) then that law is not likely to be passed.




Vote on the overall debate: Representative democracy is a better form of government than direct democracy.

What do you think?  Vote on this point below.
Absolutely Agree For
Strongly Agree For
Mostly Agree For
Partially Agree For
Neutral
Partially Agree Against
Mostly Agree Against
Strongly Agree Against
Absolutely Agree Against

Comments about this debate

There are no comments for this debate


Add your own comment

Login or register to leave a comment
Loading...